Why Strategic Planning Fails - and What to do Instead
Let’s be honest: when most teams hear “strategic planning,” they roll their eyes. And for good reason. Too often, strategic planning becomes a performative exercise—an expensive, time-consuming process that results in a glossy binder no one ever opens again.
But it doesn’t have to be that way.
At Awaken Leadership Solutions, we’ve seen firsthand how strategic planning can be transformative for teams when it’s done the right way. That starts with avoiding five common pitfalls that quietly sabotage even the most well-intentioned planning efforts.
Let’s break them down—and more importantly, how to avoid them.
Pitfall #1: You’re not ready
Strategic planning assumes your team is ready to make hard choices, face uncertainty, and embrace change. But many organizations skip over the foundational work: building trust, addressing communication breakdowns, and surfacing power dynamics.
If you haven’t done that work, your strategy is already on shaky ground.
Solution: Team coaching (with help from our Executive Team Accelerator)
Before you plan, assess. Our Executive Team Accelerator process uses robust assessments and facilitated conversations to uncover the hidden dynamics that could undermine execution later. We identify the trust gaps, communication breakdowns, and unspoken tensions so your team can move forward with clarity and cohesion.
Pitfall #2: A plan ≠ a strategy
Here’s the trap: you make a list of initiatives and call it a strategy. But a real strategy is not a to-do list—it’s a coherent theory about why your customers buy from you instead of the competition.
As this video explains, a plan is about activity. A strategy is about advantage. A strategy is the logic for how you’ll win in your market, not just how you’ll stay in the game.
Solution: Facilitated strategy conversations
At Awaken, we help teams become crystal clear on their strategy before they start planning. That means aligning your strategy and execution to your vision and taking advantage of your competitive edge in the marketplace. Whether your competitive edge is operational efficiency (think FedEx), customer intimacy, or innovation, your strategy must reflect your unique market position—and guide every decision that follows.
Pitfall #3: Oversimplifying complex problems
Many leaders try to solve adaptive challenges with technical fixes. But real strategic shifts require deeper changes in mindset and assumptions.
Take Kodak: when digital photography emerged, they doubled down on buying better paper. What they needed was a shift in identity—from a paper company to an image company.
Solution: Adaptive leadership
Drawing on the work of Ron Heifetz, Awaken helps teams to both surface and challenge the assumptions that keep them stuck. Adaptive leadership means recognizing when the problem isn’t just operational—it’s cultural, structural, or even existential. And it means leading your team through the discomfort of real change.
Pitfall #4: Overcomplicating the plan
Some strategic plans are so complex, they require a decoder ring to understand. Endless cascades of interdependent tasks, jargon-filled frameworks, and 50-slide decks that no one remembers will ensure that no one follows through.
If your team can’t explain the strategy in a sentence, they won’t execute it.
Solution: Simplicity with clarity
At Awaken, we help teams distill their strategy into a clear, memorable framework. We cut through the noise and focus on what matters most. Because strategy should be a compass, not a labyrinth.
Pitfall #5: Limited follow-through
This is where most strategies die—not in the planning, but in the execution. Teams get excited, consultants leave, and then… nothing changes.
Why? Sometimes it’s a lack of accountability. But more often, it’s because the organization wasn’t ready in the first place. (See Pitfall #1.)
Solution: Strategic execution and organizational health
Execution requires behavior change. It means aligning your people systems—hiring, development, incentives—with your strategy. It means building a healthy organization with a clear sense of purpose, a shared understanding of “why,” and a strategy that flows from that purpose.
Line of Sight Framework
At Awaken, we use the Line of Sight framework to help teams gain strategic clarity so they can better align purpose, strategy, and execution so the strategy doesn’t just live on paper, but in daily decisions and behaviors.
Final thought: Strategy thrives in healthy organizations
Strategic planning isn’t just about setting direction; it’s about building the organizational muscle to follow through. That requires clarity, courage, and a commitment to doing the hard work beneath the surface.
If your team is ready to go beyond surface-level planning and build a strategy that actually works, let’s talk. Because strategy isn’t just a document—it’s a way of thinking, leading, and growing.
Subscribe
Sign up to receive our monthly blog and resources.